Have I Been Wrong for Years?

One of my favorite arguments before the family court and the appellate courts is that fault is not a consideration in attorney’s fees. I support this argument on two primary authorities: First, in E.D.M. v. T.A.M., 307 S.C. 471, 476-77, 415 S.E.2d 812, 816 (1992), the Supreme Court held “In determining whether an attorney’s fee should be awarded, the following factors should be considered: (1) the party’s ability to pay his/her own attorney’s fee; (2) beneficial results obtained by the attorney; (3) the parties’ respective financial conditions; (4) effect of the attorney’s fee on each party’s standard of living.” Note that fault is not listed as a factor.

Second, the court of appeals, in reversing the family court held “A party’s fault in causing a divorce, however, is not a factor to be considered when awarding attorney’s fees.” Doe v. Doe, 370 S.C. 206, 219, 634 S.E.2d 51, 58 (Ct. App. 2006). This is clear, concise, and controlling.

Updating my research for my form book, Separation and Divorce in South Carolina, Forms and Comments, I read S. C. Code Ann. Section 20-3-130(H). The court, from time to time after considering the financial resources and marital fault of both parties, may order one party to pay a reasonable amount to the other for attorney fees, expert fees, investigation fees, costs, and suit money incurred in maintaining an action for divorce from the bonds of matrimony, as well as in actions for separate maintenance and support, including sums for services rendered and costs incurred before the commencement of the proceeding and after entry of judgment, pendente lite and permanently.” (Emphasis added)

I am confused. May a family court judge properly consider marital fault in deciding whether to award attorney’s fees? I am not asking what they do in practice; I am asking what they may properly do.

Categories: Attorney's Fees

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Comments

These are very helpful comments. I am starting a similar newsletter in WV for my clients and potential clients. Getting the clien...

John B on 03/02/2017
Read More

I am well aware of this conundrum. That's why I called it "When you absolutely cannot or will not hire a lawyer (for your divorce)...

J Burton Hunter III on 12/28/2016
Read More

I agree! Unbundled would be a great help to people like me. I tried to get lawyers to assist me with specific parts of the process...

Nanette Stevens on 12/27/2016
Read More

I haven't followed this thread for awhile. By far the best option is an experienced lawyer who cares about you and your family. Se...

J Burton Hunter III on 12/27/2016
Read More

I absolutely love this discussion on this subject. Involved in a divorce and forced to represent myself due to lack of funds and n...

Nanette Stevens on 12/27/2016
Read More

About The Authors

Thomas F. McDow's Profile Image
Thomas F. McDow is the author of Debating SC Family Law, a blog devoted to discussing family law and appellate court issues in South Carolina.
Erin K. Urquhart's Profile Image
Education: Spartanburg Public SchoolsWinthrop University, B.A. 2003University of South Carolina, J.D. 2006 Admitted: All South Carolina courts and the United States District Court for South Carolina, November 13, 2006 Professional Activities: South C…

Subscribe to the Debating Family Law blog by Email!